Donald J. Trump For President, Inc. et al v. Boockvar et al (4:20-cv-02078), Pennsylvania Middle District Court

Donald J. Trump For President, Inc. et al v. Boockvar et al

Pennsylvania Middle District Court
Judge:	Matthew W Brann
Case #:	4:20-cv-02078
Nature of Suit	440 Civil Rights - Other Civil Rights
Cause	28:1331 Federal Question: Other Civil Rights

Case Filed:	Nov 09, 2020
Terminated:	Nov 21, 2020

Last checked: Saturday May 08, 2021 5:23 AM EDT

Amicus Pennsylvania Senate Republican Caucus	Represented By Joshua John Voss Kleinbard LLC contact info Matthew H. Haverstick Kleinbard LLC contact info Shohin Vance Kleinbard LLC contact info
Amicus Democrats Abroad	Represented By Sean M. Shultz Hanft & Knight, P.C. contact info Jonathan Wallace contact info Remy Green Cohen&green P.L.L.C. contact info
Amicus Charlies W. Dent, et al. Amici Group	Represented By Nancy A Temple Katten & Temple LLP contact info James P. DeAngelo Mcnees Wallace & Nurick contact info Richard Bernstein contact info Richard D Bernstein contact info
Amicus Kerry Benninghoff 147 Main Capitol PO Box 202171 Harrisburg, PA 17120	Represented By Zachary Michael Wallen Chalmers & Adams LLC contact info
Amicus Bryan Cutler 139 Main Capitol Building PO Box 202100 Harrisburg, PA 17120	Represented By Zachary Michael Wallen Chalmers & Adams LLC contact info
Defendant Allegheny County Board of Elections	Represented By Mark A. Aronchick Hangley, Aronchick, Segal & Pudlin contact info Virginia Scott Scott Law Office contact info John Coit Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Michele D. Hangley Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin& Schiller contact info John B. Hill Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Andrew F. Szefi Allegheny County Law Department contact info Christina C Matthias Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Robert A Wiygul Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info
Defendant Philadelphia County Board of Elections	Represented By Mark A. Aronchick Hangley, Aronchick, Segal & Pudlin contact info John Coit Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Michele D. Hangley Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin& Schiller contact info John B. Hill Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Christina C Matthias Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Robert A Wiygul Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info
Defendant Northampton County Board of Elections	Represented By Brian J. Taylor King Spry Herman Freund & Faul LLC contact info Timothy P Brennan County Of Northampton contact info Molly E Meacham Babst, Calland, Clements And Zomnir, P.C. contact info
Defendant Montgomery County Board of Elections	Represented By Mark A. Aronchick Hangley, Aronchick, Segal & Pudlin contact info John Coit Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Michele D. Hangley Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin& Schiller contact info John B. Hill Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Christina C Matthias Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Robert A Wiygul Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info
Defendant Delaware County Board of Elections	Represented By Terence M Grugan Ballard Spahr LLP contact info Edward D. Rogers Ballard Spahr LLP contact info Elizabeth Wingfield Ballard Spahr LLP contact info Molly E Meacham Babst, Calland, Clements And Zomnir, P.C. contact info Timothy D. Katsiff Ballard Spahr LLP contact info
Defendant Chester County Board of Elections	Represented By Mark A. Aronchick Hangley, Aronchick, Segal & Pudlin contact info John Coit Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Michele D. Hangley Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin& Schiller contact info John B. Hill Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Christina C Matthias Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info Robert A Wiygul Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller contact info
Defendant Centre County Board of Elections	Represented By Elizabeth A. Dupuis Babst Calland contact info Molly E Meacham Babst, Calland, Clements And Zomnir, P.C. contact info
Defendant Kathy Boockvar	Represented By Keli M. Neary Office Of Attorney General contact info Donna A. Walsh Myers Brier & Kelly, LLP contact info Daniel T. Brier Myers Brier & Kelly, LLP contact info Daniel T Donovan Kirkland & Ellis LLP contact info John B. Dempsey Myers, Brier & Kelly, LLP contact info Nicole J. Boland Office Of Attorney General contact info Stephen Moniak Pa Office Of Attorney General contact info Karen Mascio Romano Pennsylvania Office Of Attorney General contact info
Interpleader Defendant Tim Stevens	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Jeffrey Cutler P.O. Box 2806 York, PA 17405
Intervenor Democratic National Committee	Represented By Ari Holtzblatt Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & Dorr LLP contact info Alex M Lacey Dentons Cohen & Grigsby P.C. contact info Seth Waxman contact info Robert M. Linn Dentons Cohen & Grigsby P.C. contact info John Michael Geise Perkins Coie LLP contact info Uzoma Nkwonta Perkins Coie LLP contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Lalitha D. Madduri contact info Kyle J Semroc Dentons Cohen & Grigsby P.C. contact info Clifford B. Levine Cohen & Grigsby, PC contact info Marc E Elias Perkins Coie LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Taylor Stover	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Natalie Price	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant NAACP Pennsylvania State Conference	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Ricardo Morales	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Meril Lara	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Stephanie Higgins	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Lucia Gajda	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Common Cause Pennsylvania	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Black Political Empowerment Project	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Defendant Joseph Ayeni	Represented By Dale E. Ho American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Sophia Lin Lakin American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Jon Greenbaum Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Sarah E Brannon American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Mary M McKenzie The Public Interest Law Center contact info Ezra D Rosenberg Lawyers' Committee For Civil Rights Under Law contact info Witold J. Walczak American Civil Liberties Union Of PA contact info Marian K Schneider Marian K. Schneider, Attorney-At-Law contact info David Meir Zionts Covington & Burling LLP contact info Ihaab Syed American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Shankar Duraiswamy Covington & Burling LLP contact info Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Inc contact info Claudia De Palma Public Interest Law Center contact info Benjamin D. Geffen Public Interest Law Center contact info Rani Gupta Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff David Torres SCI-R SCI at Rockview P.O. Box A Bellefonte, PA 16823	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Thomas Sankey	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Kathy Rapp	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Dasha Pruett	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Sean Parnell	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff PA Voters Alliances	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Luke Negron	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Daryl Metcalfe	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Mike Kelly	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Robert Kaufman	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Cris Dush	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Clay Breece	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Stephanie Borowicz	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Intervenor Plaintiff Kathy Barnette	Represented By Thomas W. King, III Dillon Mccandless King Coulter & Graham LLP contact info
Plaintiff Donald J. Trump For President, Inc.	Represented By Linda Ann Kerns Law Offices Of Linda Ann Kerns, LLC contact info Carolyn B. McGee Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Marc A. Scaringi Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info Rudolph William Giuliani Rudolph Giuliani, PLLC contact info John Scott contact info Douglas Bryan Hughes contact info Ronald L. Hicks, Jr Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Brian C. Caffrey Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info
Plaintiff David John Henry	Represented By Linda Ann Kerns Law Offices Of Linda Ann Kerns, LLC contact info Carolyn B. McGee Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Marc A. Scaringi Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info Rudolph William Giuliani Rudolph Giuliani, PLLC contact info John Scott contact info Douglas Bryan Hughes contact info Ronald L. Hicks, Jr Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Brian C. Caffrey Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info
Plaintiff Lawrence Roberts	Represented By Linda Ann Kerns Law Offices Of Linda Ann Kerns, LLC contact info Carolyn B. McGee Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Marc A. Scaringi Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info Rudolph William Giuliani Rudolph Giuliani, PLLC contact info John Scott contact info Douglas Bryan Hughes contact info Ronald L. Hicks, Jr Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP contact info Brian C. Caffrey Scaringi & Scaringi PC contact info
TERMINATED PARTIES
Intervenor Associated Press Terminated: 11/17/2020 450 W. 33rd St New York, NY 10001	Represented By Paula K Knudsen Burke contact info
Intervenor Daniel A. Berger Terminated: 11/12/2020	Represented By Daniel Ari Berger Gordin & Berger, P.C. contact info

	GPO Nov 17 2020 ORDER - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that AP's 150 motion to intervene is DENIED. AP's request for access to the physical courtroom is DENIED. Signed by Honorable Matthew W. Brann on 11/17/2020. (jr)
	GPO Nov 21 2020 MEMORANDUM (Order to follow as separate docket entry) re: Defendants' 127 135140145161165 Motions to Dismiss the First Amended Complaint. Signed by Honorable Matthew W. Brann on 11/21/2020. (jr) (Main Document 202 replaced on 11/23/2020 to replace states with counties in subsection D on page 11) (jr).
	GPO Nov 21 2020 ORDER (memorandum filed previously as separate docket entry) - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants' 127135140145161165 motions to dismiss the First Amended Complaint are GRANTED WITH PREJUDICE. NO LEAVE TO AMEND IS GRANTED. Defendants' 818590929698 motions to dismiss the original complaint are DENIED AS MOOT. Plaintiffs'172 motion for leave to file a second amended complaint is DENIED AS MOOT. Plaintiffs' 89182 motions for preliminary injunctioto close the case file. Signed by Honorable Matthew W. Brann on 11/21/2020. (jr)n are DENIED AS MOOT. Plaintiffs' 118171 motions regarding discovery are DENIED AS MOOT. Further motions 166180200 regarding amicus briefing and intervention are DENIED AS MOOT. The case is dismissed and the Clerk of Court is directed

Docket last updated: 3 hours ago

Tuesday, February 23, 2021
217		217 appeal USCA Amended Mandate Tue 03/30 4:07 PM USCA AMENDED MANDATE (SLC) Related: [-]

Continue to Create Account

	0:20-cv-03371 - Donald J. Trump for President, et al v. Secretary Commonwealth of PA, et al	11/22/2020
	0:20-cv-03384 - Donald J. Trump for President, et al v. Secretary Commonwealth of PA, et al	11/23/2020