New Jersey District Court
Judge:Esther Salas
Referred: Michael A Hammer
Case #: 2:95-cv-04704
Nature of Suit370 Torts - Personal Property - Other Fraud
Cause28:1332 Diversity-Fraud
Case Filed:Sep 01, 1995
Re-opened:Feb 17, 2021
Terminated:Feb 17, 2021
Amicus
THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA
Claimant
CHARLES T. DUFFY
Claimant
GERARD DUFFY
Claimant
KATHLEEN D. CORNELSKE
Claimant
MICHELLE BLACKMON
Claimant
PAUL V. GIATTINA
Claimant
THOMAS M. SULLIVAN
Consol Plaintiff
DONNA M. SCHUFF
Consol Plaintiff
JEAN ANN SHANNON
Consol Plaintiff
JOHN S. SHANNON
Defendant
ANGELO TERRANOVA
Defendant
AZARIAH EDWARDS
Defendant
BEHZAD ZANDI
Defendant
BILL S. PINKERTON
Defendant
BOB SCHULTZE
Defendant
BRENDAN T. BYRNE
Defendant
BURTON G. MALKIEL
Defendant
CAMILIO GUTTIEREZ
Defendant
CAROLYNE K. DAVIS
Defendant
CHARLES CELLA
Defendant
CHARLES DUNN
Defendant
CHARLES J. MOLLICA
Defendant
CHARLES J. WHATLEY
Defendant
CHARLES R. MOORER
Defendant
CHARLES S. SPERAZZA JR.
Defendant
CLINT CORREAL
Defendant
CLIVE ANDERSON
Defendant
CLYDE PATE
Defendant
CURTIS SIMPSON
Defendant
DALTON R. WALLEY
Defendant
DANIEL ARMENTROUT
Defendant
DANIEL MCFARLAND
Defendant
DAVE MARTINEZ
Defendant
DAVID GAGE
Defendant
DAVID HORVATH
Defendant
DAVID J. CARNAROLI
Defendant
DAVID LAMB
Defendant
DAVID ROBERT GOLSON
Defendant
DENNIS MULLIGAN
Defendant
DENNIS OWENS
Defendant
DIANA SCHULMAN
Defendant
DIANE VANDERBROOK
Defendant
DICK HILLBERRY
Defendant
DON HENSEL
Defendant
DON MUSGRAVE
Defendant
DON SPIVEY
Defendant
DON W. MOONEY
Defendant
DONALD E. PROCKNOW
Defendant
DONALD G. SOUTHWELL
Defendant
DOROTHY K. LIGHT
Defendant
DOUG MCCOWEN
Defendant
DOUG PAVLICK
Defendant
ED DARE
Defendant
EDWARD GUY
Defendant
EDWARD KANE
Defendant
EUGENE M. O'HARA
Defendant
FERMIN PEREZ
Defendant
FRANCES C. SMITH
Defendant
FRANK A. MARASCO & ASSOCIATES
Defendant
FRANK CONNIZZO
Defendant
FRANK J. TOSCHES
Defendant
FRANKLIN J. PROVANCE JR.
Defendant
FRED DIMMEL II
Defendant
GARNETT L. KEITH JR.
Defendant
GENE K. DWORAK
Defendant
GEORGE CLARK
Defendant
GEORGE KRESGE
Defendant
GEORGE MAUTZ
Defendant
GREG ULIATOWSKI
Defendant
GREG WEAR
Defendant
HANK LAHTI
Defendant
HARRY AXFORD
Defendant
HOMAYOUN ARVIN
Defendant
HORACE R. HILLBERRY
Defendant
HORACE RICHARD HILLBERRY
Defendant
IRA HYATT
Defendant
J. W. (JIM) FOLKES
Defendant
JACK SULLIVAN
Defendant
JAMES BYRNE
Defendant
JAMES C. KELLOGG
Defendant
JAMES DAHL
Defendant
JAMES E. BURKE
Defendant
JAMES E. BUSH
Defendant
JAMES G. AFFLECK
Defendant
JAMES J. HYBIL
Defendant
JAMES KEEGAN
Defendant
JAMES LANKSTER
Defendant
JAMES TURNER
Defendant
JAROL D. LAKE
Defendant
JERALD BENSON
Defendant
JERRY BURKLAND
Defendant
JERRY L. LEBLANC
Defendant
JIM T. LISTON
Defendant
JIMMY BLUE JR.
Defendant
JOE WOLF
Defendant
JOHN DOE
Defendant
JOHN MICHAEL GORMAN
Defendant
JOHN R. OPEL
Defendant
JOHN STEPHEN SHOOK
Defendant
JOHN WILSON
Defendant
JON F. HANSON
Defendant
JOSEPH ALBER
Defendant
JOSEPH DELPONTE
Defendant
JOSEPH PICHIARALLO
Defendant
KENNETH DITTMAN
Defendant
KEVIN CREGAN
Defendant
KEVIN MACKENZIE
Defendant
LAURA GENTILE
Defendant
LENNY SANSOME
Defendant
LEROY LANG
Defendant
LISLE C. CARTER JR.
Defendant
LOUIS CAPONE
Defendant
LUCIA T. MIDDENDORF
Defendant
Mark Gitig
Defendant
MARK RADERMACHER
Defendant
MARSHALL MARSHALL MEREDITH TRIPP SPRING, III
Defendant
MARTIN PFINSGRAF
Defendant
MENZO D. CHENEY
Defendant
MICHAEL J. BUCKLEY
Defendant
MICHAEL SCHUSTER
Defendant
MIKE OVERSTREET
Defendant
MOUNT PLEASANT AGENCY
Defendant
NANCY QUIGLEY
Defendant
NOAH REIL JR.
Defendant
NORMA R. CARLOUGH
Defendant
P. ROY VAGELOS
Defendant
PASQUALE J. ROMEO
Defendant
PAUL A. VOLCKER
Defendant
PAUL DOROSH
Defendant
PAULETTE PRICE
Defendant
PRUCO LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, a wholly owned subisdiary of The Prudential Insurance Company of America
Defendant
PRUCO SECURITIES CORPORATION
Defendant
PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA
Defendant
R. R. PALKA
Defendant
RAFAEL FERNANDEZ
Defendant
RICHARD B. ALBRIGHT
Defendant
RICHARD BELDING
Defendant
RICHARD DINGS
Defendant
RICHARD HALLER
Defendant
RICHARD HILLBERRY
Defendant
RICHARD M. THOMSON
Defendant
Richard Maschmann
Defendant
RICHARD SADOWSKI
Defendant
ROBERT A. BECK
Defendant
ROBERT C. WINTERS
Defendant
ROBERT DRABIK
Defendant
ROBERT GENTILE
Defendant
ROBERT J. BOUTILLIER
Defendant
ROBERT J. GOETZ
Defendant
ROBERT M. SCHABERLE
Defendant
RON D. BARBARO
Defendant
SAMUEL MADDOX
Defendant
SOL HICKS
Defendant
STANLEY C. VANNESS
Defendant
STEPHEN T. SUPER
Defendant
STEVE LEMELL
Defendant
STEVEN KATTKE
Defendant
TED S. SORCE
Defendant
THADDEUS E. POHORYLO
Defendant
THOMAS BREWER
Defendant
TINA SUPER
Defendant
TYLER AUSTIN
Defendant
VANAUGHN HARDY
Defendant
VERNON B. EATON
Defendant
VINCENT A. LAZZARA
Defendant
WARREN POURCIAU
Defendant
WILLIAM EARL MANLEY
Defendant
WILLIAM H. GRAY III
Defendant
WILLIAM HEIN
Defendant
WILLIAM SWATS
Defendant
WILLIAM W. BOESCHENSTEIN
In Re
IN RE THE PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA SALES PRACTICES LITIGATION
Intervenor Defendant
DOW JONES AND COMPANY
Intervenor Plaintiff
KATHRYN JOHNSON
Intervenor Plaintiff
MASSACHUSETTS ATTORNEY GENERAL
Intervenor Plaintiff
MASSACHUSETTS COMMISSIONER OF INSURANCE
Intervenor Plaintiff
RICHARD JOHNSON
Mediator
RODNEY A. MAX
Movant
ALLIANCE BANK
Movant
ANDREW W. TURK JR.
Movant
ANTOINETTE ADAMAKIS
Movant
ASHLEY BUCKMAN
Movant
AYOKUNNU O. ARE
Movant
CALVIN L. TODD
Movant
CARL D. HELTON
Movant
CAROL ANN GRIBBONS
Movant
CAROL WHINERY
Movant
DANIEL MATHIAS
Movant
DAVID SILVA
Movant
DIANE NICKOLSON
Movant
DOLORES M. CIMINO
Movant
DONALD H. SCHMIDT
Movant
ELEANOR REED
Movant
FAITH A. MOODY
Movant
FLOR WILLIAMS
Movant
FRED L. NEFF
Movant
GEORGE M. STAURSKY
Movant
GERELENE SCHMIDT
Movant
HALINA KRYK
Movant
HELEN KOENIG
Movant
HENRY WILLIAMS
Movant
HERVE GIARD JR.
Movant
ISADORE A/ RAPASADI
Movant
J. PATRICK MARTIN
Movant
JACK FARBMAN
Movant
JAMES ELLIOTT
Movant
JAMES H. FISH
Movant
JAMES H. LINDSEY
Movant
JAMES MEINSMA
Movant
JANET GRADY
Movant
JOAN HICKS
Movant
JOHN A. GUY SR.
Movant
JOHN J. MASSARO
Movant
JOHN L. PRUETER
Movant
JOHNNIE DAVIS
Movant
KEN ROSE COMPANY
Movant
KENNETH CATES
Movant
KRISTIN S. MILHAN
Movant
LINDA HANAN
Movant
MARGARET L. FISHER
Movant
MARVIN LOWE
Movant
MARY ALICE MATHIAS
Movant
MARY C. STRATTAN
Movant
MICHAEL JAY PERLMAN
Movant
MICHAEL P. MALAKOFF
Movant
MOISES DABDOUB
Movant
NANCY D. JONAS
Movant
NICHOLAS M. CHIONCHIO
Movant
RICHARD G. MILHAN
Movant
RICHARD L. WATTERS
Movant
RICKY NICKOLSON
Movant
ROBERT HANAN
Movant
RODNEY E. MOODY
Movant
RODNEY GRADY
Movant
ROGER JIRIKOVIC
Movant
SAMUEL S. RAPASADI
Movant
STACY WHITMAN
Movant
STEPHANIE KOENIG
Movant
SUSAN REED
Movant
TATIANA DEAR
Movant
THE NEFF LAW FIRM
Movant
THERESA A. FREEMAN
Movant
WACLAW KRYK
Movant
WILLIAM H. KIRK
Movant
WYNNE WHITMAN
Notice Only
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
Notice Only
LIAISON COUNSEL
Notice Only
MELVYN I. WEISS
Notice Only
MICHAEL I. HYMAN
Notice Only
NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE
Objector
CALIFORNIA
Objector
EDWARD GINSBERG
Objector
LESTER A. GARRINGER
Objector
NANCY PARNELL
Objector
SHERRY LYNN TREADWAY
Objector
TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE
Objector
UAW-GM LEGAL SERVICES PLAN
Plaintiff
ADELL TROTTER
Plaintiff
ALBERT J. MALLETT
Plaintiff
ALEXANDER BALINT
Plaintiff
Alicia Wolin
Plaintiff
ALLAN W. AMLEE
Plaintiff
ANNETTE D. LOVETT
Plaintiff
ANTHONY CAVALIERI
Plaintiff
ANTHONY J. SGARLATA
Plaintiff
ANTHONY M. MONTVILLE
Plaintiff
ANTHONY SANSERVINO
Plaintiff
ANTHONY YBARRA
Plaintiff
ARTHUR O. DICKHAUSEN
Plaintiff
BENJAMIN A. ALLOCCO
Plaintiff
BETTE TAYLOR
Plaintiff
BETTY CHOLEWINSKI
Plaintiff
BETTY W. HAVENS
Plaintiff
BOBBIE DIEBOLD TUDOR
Plaintiff
BRENT A. BEAUVIAS
Plaintiff
CARLOS FREANER FIGUEROA
Plaintiff
CAROL A. GRIBBONS
Plaintiff
CAROL ANN LEMIEUX
Plaintiff
CAROL ANNE HALES
Plaintiff
CAROL NICHOLSON
Plaintiff
CAROL SHIGLEY
Plaintiff
CAROLYN A. SHIGLEY
Plaintiff
CHARLES A. BRANDEBURG
Plaintiff
CHARLES CURTIS
Plaintiff
CHARLES E. JONES
Plaintiff
CHARLES ELLIOTT
Plaintiff
CHARLES J. HARRIS
Plaintiff
CHARLES K. BERGER
Plaintiff
CLARA BRAGELMAN
Plaintiff
COLEMAN BELCER
Plaintiff
CORA MCCOY
Plaintiff
D'ANDRE LEWIS
Plaintiff
DAN B. HOUSER
Plaintiff
DARRELL DUNN
Plaintiff
DEBORA SANSERVINO KRUEGER
Plaintiff
DEBRA L. PIERZINA
Plaintiff
DIANE HACKETT
Plaintiff
DONALD HALES
Plaintiff
DONALD SKOWVRON
Plaintiff
DONNA L. HANCOCK
Plaintiff
DORA DAVIS
Plaintiff
DORIS J. FAY
Plaintiff
DOROTHY V. JONES
Plaintiff
DREW DUNNAGAN
Plaintiff
DUB DAVIS
Plaintiff
E. EUGENE PRICE
Plaintiff
EARLINE FARMER
Plaintiff
EDWARD E. ENGLISH
Plaintiff
EDWARD F. GAMBLE JR.
Plaintiff
ELAINE A. BALINT
Plaintiff
ELIAS DAVLIN
Plaintiff
ELIZA JANE JOHNSON
Plaintiff
ELIZABETH KUCHAS
Plaintiff
ELOIS LAUDERDALE
Plaintiff
EMELLA UPSHAW
Plaintiff
ERNESTINE HARRIS
Plaintiff
ERNESTINE STEELE
Plaintiff
ESTELLA SANDERS HURT
Plaintiff
ETHEL L. WELLER
Plaintiff
EUGENE KROLL
Plaintiff
EUGENE MURRAY
Plaintiff
EVA DAVIS
Plaintiff
FRANCES M. CRAWFORD
Plaintiff
FRANCINE LAUDERDALE
Plaintiff
FRANK J. COSCARELLA
Plaintiff
FRANK MARASCO
Plaintiff
G. ANNETTE NANTZ
Plaintiff
GARY DUGAN
Plaintiff
GARY J. MORROW
Plaintiff
GENE WHITE
Plaintiff
GEORGE A. ZOLLER
Plaintiff
GEORGE BOOTZ
Plaintiff
GERALD A. HANCOCK
Plaintiff
GLENMORE KIDD
Plaintiff
GREGORY KNUTSON
Plaintiff
H. ELTON WOODWARD
Plaintiff
H. ELTON WOODWARD JR.
Plaintiff
HARRY J. SHIGLEY
Plaintiff
HARVEY WILBORN
Plaintiff
HELEN COMER
Plaintiff
HERBERT SCHULTE
Plaintiff
HERMAN "PAT" SCHANNEP
Plaintiff
HUGO I. FLORES LUJAN
Plaintiff
IRENE H. DICKHAUSEN
Plaintiff
IRENE SANSERVINO
Plaintiff
JAMES E. WILTON
Plaintiff
JAMES GRIFFIS
Plaintiff
JAMES M. POCARO
Plaintiff
JAMES W. JORDAN
Plaintiff
JAN SKOWVRON
Plaintiff
JANE BOOTZ
Plaintiff
JANIS L. GLANDIS
Plaintiff
JEAN DESMOND
Plaintiff
JERRY SIMMONS
Plaintiff
JESSIE DAVIS
Plaintiff
JODY LYNN SIMMONS
Plaintiff
JOHN A. HUNTER
Plaintiff
JOHN A. KITTLE
Plaintiff
JOHN D. COOPER
Plaintiff
JOHN DAVIS
Plaintiff
JOHN E. VETTER
Plaintiff
JOHN EUGENE GOODART
Plaintiff
JOHN F. MACK
Plaintiff
JOHN J. FERRIER
Plaintiff
JOHN MALLARD
Plaintiff
JOHN SHIGLEY
Plaintiff
JOHNNIE F. DAVIS
Plaintiff
JOSEPH CARNEY
Plaintiff
JOSEPH L. HUNTER
Plaintiff
JOSEPH T. MURPHY
Plaintiff
JOSEPHINE TONEY
Plaintiff
JUDITH M. GROTH
Plaintiff
KAREN J. WOLFE
Plaintiff
KATHRYN W. MURPHY
Plaintiff
KENNETH R. YOUNG
Plaintiff
KEVIN CORNWELL
Plaintiff
KYLE JAY GOODART
Plaintiff
LARRY WACHTLER
Plaintiff
LAURA SIMMONS
Plaintiff
LAVAUGHN JOHNS
Plaintiff
LAWRENCE ALMEDA
Plaintiff
LAWRENCE THOMPSON
Plaintiff
LEOMA A. BELL
Plaintiff
LESTER H. GROTH
Plaintiff
LEWIS D. SMITH
Plaintiff
LIBERO PACIONI
Plaintiff
LOLA MEYER
Plaintiff
LORI K. ANDERSON
Plaintiff
LOUIS C. BRACCINI
Plaintiff
MAHMOUD OMMAT MOHAMMADI
Plaintiff
MARCUS K. DUDLEY
Plaintiff
MARGARET DUNNAGAN
Plaintiff
MARIA ALMEDA
Plaintiff
MARTIN DORFNER
Plaintiff
MARVIN PESSES
Plaintiff
MARY C. ALLOCCO
Plaintiff
MARY CARNEY
Plaintiff
MARY HARBOUR
Plaintiff
MELINDA L. KING
Plaintiff
MICHAEL D. GORDON
Plaintiff
MICHAEL H. PIERZINA
Plaintiff
MICHAEL JOSEPH JOHNSON
Plaintiff
MICHAEL R. WEAVER
Plaintiff
MILDRED B. MURPHY
Plaintiff
MILDRED MOLITOR
Plaintiff
MITCHELL KRAUSE
Plaintiff
MYRILL RINEHART
Plaintiff
NADA N. KNIGHT
Plaintiff
NATHANIEL UPSHAW
Plaintiff
NICHOLAS L. LUMAN
Plaintiff
NICOLE TIERNEY
Plaintiff
OLIN B. DAVIS
Plaintiff
ORVIAL T. HALTOM
Plaintiff
PATRICIA A. COMER
Plaintiff
PAUL G. MADDY
Plaintiff
PAUL HOLLINS
Plaintiff
PHILLIS E. AMLEE
Plaintiff
PHYLLIS FISHER
Plaintiff
RADIE MURPHY
Plaintiff
RANDY TANNER
Plaintiff
RAY ALCANTARA
Plaintiff
RAY LOGGINS
Plaintiff
RAYMOND P. SHOW
Plaintiff
REBECCA MONTERO
Plaintiff
RICHARD C. TRERICE
Plaintiff
RICHARD E. GREGORY
Plaintiff
RICHARD J. GLANDIS
Plaintiff
RICHARD K. WOLFE
Plaintiff
RICHARD P. KRELL
Plaintiff
RICK A. MARTIN
Plaintiff
RICKY H. WALTERS
Plaintiff
ROBERT H. YOUNGHOUSE
Plaintiff
ROBERT KOLHOFF
Plaintiff
ROBERT L. CHECH
Plaintiff
RONALD A. BELL
Plaintiff
RONALD CARROLL
Plaintiff
RONALD CHOLEWINSKI
Plaintiff
ROSA DAVIS
Plaintiff
ROSA SICONOLFI
Plaintiff
ROSE M. JORDAN
Plaintiff
ROSE STEVENS
Plaintiff
ROSIE B. FERRIER
Plaintiff
ROY ALLEN GOODART II
Plaintiff
ROY TONEY
Plaintiff
SALVATORE FLAUTO
Plaintiff
SAM B. WRIGHT
Plaintiff
SANDRA DIEBOLD CARVER
Plaintiff
SHADMAN MOHAMMADI
Plaintiff
SHAYAN OMMAT MOHAMMADI
Plaintiff
SHIRLEY MYSZKA
Plaintiff
SIN JA HALTOM
Plaintiff
STEPHEN A. PSENO
Plaintiff
STEVEN J. DEMARAIS
Plaintiff
STOUDT DISTRIBUTING CO., INC.
Plaintiff
SUSAN DUGAN
Plaintiff
SYBIL G. DUDLEY
Plaintiff
SYLVIA K. SCHAFFRATH
Plaintiff
TERRY V. INGRAM
Plaintiff
THEODORE WILLENBRING
Plaintiff
THOMAS M. TEBO JR.
Plaintiff
THOMAS T. CERCHIA
Plaintiff
TIMOTHY SIMMONS
Plaintiff
TIMOTHY SKOWVRON
Plaintiff
TONI WACHTLER
Plaintiff
TOURAN OMMAT MOHAMMADI
Plaintiff
VINCENT KUCHAS
Plaintiff
VIOLA FISHER
Plaintiff
VIRGILIA DAVERN
Plaintiff
WANDA CAVALIERI
Plaintiff
WAYNE D. CONNER
Plaintiff
WILHELMINA BELCER
Plaintiff
WILLIAM HARBOUR
Plaintiff
WILLIAM J. FAY
Plaintiff
WILLIAM J. YOUSKO
Plaintiff
WILLIAM RONALD RICHARDS
Plaintiff
WILLIAM YAMNITZ
Plaintiff
WILLIE C. ALLEN
Plaintiff
WILLIE GOODART
Plaintiff
WILMA RINEHART
Plaintiff
WILMER C. SIGWARTH
Plaintiff
WILSON HAVENS
Plaintiff
WILSON M. BIGGERS JR.
Plaintiff
YVONNE HUNTER
Plaintiff Consolidated
DONNA M. SCHUFF
Plaintiff Consolidated
JEAN ANN SHANNON
Plaintiff Consolidated
JOHN S. SHANNON
Respondent
CLAY HORNSBY
Respondent
J. BRUCE MILLER
Special Master
PETER CIOLINO

GPO Nov 15 2005
OPINION . Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 11/14/05. (DD, )
GPO May 26 2006
OPINION . Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 5/26/06. (DD, )
GPO Sep 27 2007
OPINION. Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 9/25/07. (DD, )
GPO Jan 11 2008
OPINION. Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 1/11/2008. (mn, )
GPO Jan 14 2008
ORDER granting 2009 Motion to enjoin Daniel and Mary Alice Mathias. Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 1/11/2008. (mn, )
GPO Jun 03 2015
OPINION. Signed by Judge Dickinson R. Debevoise on 6/3/15. (DD, )
GPO Feb 17 2021
OPINION. Signed by Judge Esther Salas on 2/17/2021. (ams, )

Docket last updated: 05/05/2024 11:59 PM EDT
Wednesday, February 17, 2021
2054 2054 2 pgs order Order Wed 02/17 2:07 PM
ORDER that Defendant's2038 Motion to Enjoin Plaintiffs from litigating Tierney v. The Prudential Ins. Co. of America is DENIED, etc. Signed by Judge Esther Salas on 2/17/2021. (ams, )
Related: [-]
2053 2053 13 pgs order Opinion Wed 02/17 2:04 PM
OPINION. Signed by Judge Esther Salas on 2/17/2021. (ams, )
Related: [-]
utility Terminate Civil Case Wed 02/17 2:08 PM
***Civil Case Terminated pursuant to2054 Order. (ams, )
Related: [-]